Conservative radio host Erick Erickson is warning Republicans that Vice President JD Vance could be a historically risky pick for the party’s 2028 presidential nomination. He says the track record of sitting vice presidents who run to succeed their bosses is not encouraging.
In a video posted this week titled “History’s warning for JD Vance,” the Georgia-based host made the case that being next in line has been a path to the nomination but not to the White House.
“One hundred percent of vice presidents who seek the nomination after their president is term-limited, in the last hundred years, have gotten the nomination,” Erickson said. He then explained why that is not good news. “Bush is the big exception,” he said, referring to George H.W. Bush, who won the presidency in 1988 after serving under Ronald Reagan.
“It is very, very, very rare for vice presidents to actually win general elections,” Erickson added.
History backs up his point. Richard Nixon won the Republican nomination in 1960 after serving under Dwight Eisenhower and lost to John F. Kennedy. Al Gore won the Democratic nomination in 2000 after eight years under Bill Clinton and lost to George W. Bush.
Erickson said that is part of Vance’s problem, and then turned to what he sees as the stakes for the GOP. He argued there is a lot on the line for Republicans in 2028. He asked conservatives who believe the country faces an existential crisis whether they want to gamble on a nominee history has not favored. “Do you really want to take the chance?” he asked.
On his radio show, Erickson has said a governor would be a better fit for the party. He has named Virginia’s Glenn Youngkin, Georgia’s Brian Kemp, Florida’s Ron DeSantis and New Hampshire’s Kelly Ayotte. He has also floated Secretary of State Marco Rubio as a possible “bridge” candidate.
Erickson has also contrasted Vance with Rubio in recent days. He praised Rubio for going on camera from Asia to reassure Americans that the recent bank and tech outages were not a cyberattack. Meanwhile, he noted, Vance canceled an appearance at an Andrew Ross Sorkin conference and briefed reporters on background as a “senior government official.”
Erickson is not the only voice on the right raising doubts. After Republicans lost both chambers of Congress in this month’s midterm elections, the Daily Wire’s Ben Shapiro said a Vance candidacy would face a “rough road.” Commentator Jonah Goldberg called Vance “the biggest single loser” of election night.
Vance himself blamed the midterm defeat on the war with Iran in a lengthy post on X the morning after the election, a rare public break with President Trump. On Friday, he deferred to the president when asked whether the war was worth the political cost.
The 2028 field is already informally taking shape. DeSantis took a shot at Vance in a New York Times interview published Friday, saying the vice president will struggle to win over voters unhappy with the current administration. At a White House briefing the same day, Trump jokingly asked new chief of staff Stephen Miller whether he wanted to run for president while Vance and Rubio stood beside him.
No major Republican has formally entered the race. Vance and Rubio are still widely seen as the top contenders, but critics like Erickson are urging the party to think twice before handing the nomination to the sitting vice president.
